Consignment Sales around Columbus, plus Consignment Stores

Buying new seasonal clothing, school clothing, toys, or baby items can get expensive. Babies and kids grow out of their stuff so quickly that consignment sales can save you lots of money – you’ll get gently used items for a fraction of the price new.

There are several upcoming consignment sales around Columbus for kids’ clothes, toys, gifts, or maternity and baby items, and much more. If you have items to sell, please check the individual sale pages for instructions on how to become a seller. It’s a great way to earn money so that you can purchase the next size of clothing for your kids!

I’ve also included a list of consignment stores around Columbus in case you can’t make it to the sales.

Are we missing one? Please email news@columbusonthecheap.com if you know of a sale or a store that isn’t listed. Make sure you don’t miss other great deals and events by subscribing to Columbus on the Cheap by email.

Want to SELL at a consignment sale? Click on the links below and look at the seller resources! It’s a great way to make some money from clothing, toys, and equipment that your family no longer needs! Prepping for the sales takes some time, so if you’re decluttering, start gathering stuff you may want to sell in totes and boxes now! Kids clothing, outdoor toys (bikes and such), and baby equipment sell particularly well – but I’ve had great luck selling nearly anything at these sales.

2021 Consignment Sales Around Columbus

New! Three Bags Full Online Sale

February 2-6 (tentative)
Newark, Ohio

Shop (and sell) online through Three Bags Full with this new trial pop-up sale.

Purchase online during the sale, and pickup curbside at location tba in Newark. More details tba.

Pickerington Three Bags Full

tentative: Feb 28-March 6
The Grove Community Christian Church: 3420 Blacklick-Eastern Rd NW Baltimore, OH 43105

Features 350 families selling THOUSANDS OF ITEMS. Find thousands of quality, gently-used items for the whole family (clothes, toys, purses, baby equipment & more) and new with tag items. Consignors price their own items, keep 60-80% (earn more by helping Sale Week) and shop before the public.

Three Bags Full Sales offer free shopping and parking.
Sellers get to shop early for the best selection!
Early Access “Shopping Appointment” can be purchased for Wednesday for limited entry for maximum social distancing & best selection. Doors close at 9pm. Standby entry not available during these times. Adults only. Masks based on current Ohio mandates. Appointments available Sept. 2 @ 8pm. Appointments can also be purchased for Friday evening 50% off sale.
Public shopping begins on Thursday-Saturday afternoon. Entry is subject to capacity and shoppers may have to wait standby until other shoppers exit
Thu., (10am-7pm).
Fri., (10am-2pm). Friday night 50% off sale 7pm-9pm. 50% off tags with “dots” available with shopping appointments only
Sat., (10am-2pm) *50% off tags with “dots” & Flash Sales. 5pm-6pm 50-75% off all items
Visa & MasterCard with photo ID (Minimum $10) and cash accepted.

Columbus Hilliard Kids Clothing & Toy Pop Up with Three Bags Full Children’s Consignment Sale

tentative: March 14-20
Columbus near Tuttle

Features 350 families selling THOUSANDS OF ITEMS.
Find thousands of quality, gently-used items for the whole family (clothes, toys, purses, baby equipment & more) and new with tag Melissa & Doug, Playmobil and Gymboree. Consignors price their own items, keep 65-80% (earn more by helping Sale Week) and shop before the public.

Three Bags Full Sales offer free shopping and parking. Early shopping tickets can be purchase if available. Sellers get to shop early for the best selection!

Early Access “Shopping Appointment” can be purchased for early limited entry, maxim

um social distancing & best selection. Standby entry not available during these times. Adults only. Masks based on current Ohio mandates.

tba: Appointments beginning at 5:30pm
tba evening appointments. Most items 50% off

Public shopping begins on Thursday. Entry is subject to capacity and shoppers may have to wait standby until other shoppers exit

THURDAY: 4pm-9pm
FRIDAY: 10am-6pm
SATURDAY: 10am-4pm (flash sales)
SUNDAY: 10am-2pm* (50% off most items) & 5pm-6pm (50% or 75% off all items during Power Hour)

What you need to know: Bring your own bag (no bags provided), or buy a HUGE green 3BF bag for $5 while supplies last. Visa, MC with photo ID ($10 minimim) or cash, $2 processing fee added to all transactions. All sales final. Find out about the “Be Green” Shopper Club and Super Star Shopper Club that will allow you to shop early at future sales!

Johnstown Croton Three Bags Full

tentative: April 17-24
Hartford Fairgrounds: 14028 Fairgrounds Rd. Croton, OH 43013

Features 400 families selling THOUSANDS OF ITEMS. *Fri night & Sat all “red dot” tags are 50% off
Find thousands of quality, gently-used items for the whole family (clothes, toys, purses, baby equipment & more) and new with tag items. Consignors price their own items, keep 65-80% (earn more by helping Sale Week) and shop before the public.

Three Bags Full Sales offer free shopping and parking.
Sellers get to shop early on Tuesday for the best selection!
Early Access “Shopping Appointment” can be purchased for Wednesday and Thursday for limited entry, maximum social distancing & best selection. Doors close at 9pm. Standby entry not available during these times. Adults only. Masks based on current Ohio mandates. Appointments available Sept. 2 @ 8pm. Appointments can also be purchased for Friday evening 50% off sale.
Public shopping begins on Friday. Entry is subject to capacity and shoppers may have to wait standby until other shoppers exit
Fri., (10am-11am At Risk Shoppers; 11am-6pm)
Sat., (10am-4pm). 50% off sale 7pm-9pm. 50% off tags with “dots” available with shopping appointments only
Sun, (10am-2pm) *50% off tags with “dots” & Flash Sales. 5pm-6pm 50-75% off all items
Visa & MasterCard with photo ID (Minimum $10) and cash accepted.

MOPS Resale at the Naz

April 17, 2021 and fall tba
Grove City Church of the Nazarene: 4770 Hoover Rd, Grove City, OH 43123.

Hours are 8 a.m. – 12 p.m.
Cash and check only

Mother’s of Multiples of East Columbus
Spring (tba) and fall (tba)
Messiah Lutheran Church, 1200 Waggoner Rd. Reynoldsburg

Hours are 9 am to noon
Early bird shopping starts at 8:30 am with a $2 donation to Columbus March of Dimes
Kids Clothing, Toy, and Equipment sale
credit card, cash, and check accepted

MOPS @ Grace Polaris
Spring (tba) and Fall (tba)
Grace Polaris Main Campus, 8225 Worthington-Galena Road, Westerville, OH 43081

Hours are 8 a.m. – 12 p.m. (1 – 3 p.m. is the half-off sale)
Gently used infant-elementary clothes, bassinets, highchairs, strollers, cribs, maternity clothes, bouncers, crib bedding, costumes, school uniforms, shoes, coats, books, toys, etc.
Accepts cash, check and credit cards

Westerville Baby & Kids Bargain Boutique & Maternity Sale
Summer tba
Westerville Community Center, 350 N Cleveland Ave., Westerville, Ohio 43082

Hours are 9 am – 12 pm
Buy or sell usable maternity clothes, children’s clothing, toys and furniture. Parking for event is at the Sports Complex with shuttle service available.
Admission: a non-perishable food item which will be donated to a local food bank.

Christmas Extravaganza! A Pop Up Shop in Pickerington hosted by Three Bags Full
tba 2020
THE GROVE, 3420 Blacklick Eastern Rd NW, Baltimore, Ohio 43105

Friday, Nov. 8: 6pm: $5 admission at the door per adult or $3 in advance. (Ticket link below) or 8pm: $1 admission at the door
Saturday, Nov.9: 10am-3pm $1 admission at the door. Santa and his elves will make an appearance! on Saturday: 11:30am-2:30pm (approximate times)
Kids are free
Exclusive new with tag, excellent condition & giftable clothing for the whole family plus toys, baby gear, shoes, handbags plus Christmas and Holiday indoor/outdoor decor. Exclusive handcrafted, farm fresh and boutique vendors to help you start your Christmas shopping.

Just Between Friends Consignment Sale
Spring tba
New Location! Club Ohio Indoor Training Facility, 6923 Rings Rd, Dublin, OH 43016

Upscale and Recycled Baby, Kid and Maternity Items. Tickets are free, but required for certain shopping times. Click here for ticket links.

Wed & Thurs, Aug 5 & 6 | Drop Off: See Consignor Details page for more information.
Thurs Aug 6 | Community Presale Day!
4pm-8pm | Ticket required for special guests. (Special guests include: 1st Time Parents/Grandparents, Teachers, and 1st Responders)
4:30pm-8pm | Back To School Community Presale. Tickets Required for Everyone. Pick your ticket here.
Friday Aug 7 | Opening Day | Freebie Friday! 9am-8pm | $2 Admission today only, however get your FREE Ticket here. | Freebie Friday! Enter to Win baby equipment and so much more. | Must be present to enter not to win.
Saturday Aug 8 | Public Sale: 8am-3pm | FREE admission – no ticket needed for adults (Kids need a FREE ticket for Family Fun Fest)!
Saturday Aug 8 | Back to School Free Family Fun Fest: 10am-12pm | Free Ticket here | Meet Marshall from Paw Patrol, get your face painted by “Pretty As A Princess Parties”, play games and so much more. (Tickets are need for adequate supplies.)
Saturday Aug 8 | Half Price Presale: 4pm-8pm | Tickets Required for Everyone. Get your ticket here. (Only items with NO STARS are half off)
Sunday Aug 9 | Huge Discount Day | 50% & 75% Off! 9am-12pm | 50% Off All Items Without A Star & 75% Off All Items With A “D”.

Columbus Mother’s of Twins Club Kids Clothing & Equipment Sale
Spring tba
Resolute Athletic Complex, 3599 Chiller Lane, Columbus, Ohio 43219

Largest children’s consignment sale in Columbus, and one of the largest Twins Club sales in the United States for re-sale of maternity, baby, child, tween and junior covering over 45,000 square feet.

Hours are 8 a.m. – 11 a.m. ($2 for 7 a.m. admission)
Featuring fall and winter clothing and gear: As always we will also carry maternity clothing, baby gear (strollers, high chairs, car seats, etc.), toys, books and kids/baby room decor.
Cash, check and credit cards accepted.

Rhea Lana North Columbus
Spring tba and Fall tba
location tba

Rhea Lana’s is an upscale semi-annual children’s consignment sale with sales twice a year, once in the spring and again in the fall. You’ll find clothing, furniture, baby equipment, toys, and more, priced at 25-35% of retail. Consignors earn 65 – 75% of their sales. See Facebook page here.

Presale Ticket options (before store opens to general public)

PLATINUM: $20 (includes 1 guest) This is FIRST DIBS on all our awesome items.
GOLD: $15 (includes 1 guest) Want to be there opening night? Gold is a great option! You’ll get great value of shopping by being in the second hour, with all our items being unique!
SILVER: $10 (includes 1 guest) This is our final paid presale and is great value if you can’t make it Friday night for Platinum or Gold!
MOM TO BE/TEACHER/MILITARY. The first of our FREE presale tiers (after consignors ) these are for our new moms, our fantastic teachers and service families!
ONLINE GUESTS: If you follow Rhea Lana’s of North Columbus on Facebook or Insta, you can sign up for a free pass before our Early Bird shopping!
EARY BIRD: This is the final option before we open fully to the public

Local Consignment Stores

Looking to buy or sell on consignment at a store location? There are several great consignment stores to check out around Columbus for everyone in the family.

Clothes Mentor: Juniors, Women’s, Plus sizes, Maternity (my favorite place for Maternity!)
(4 locations)

Once Upon a Child: Baby & kids clothes, toys and baby items
6 locations in the Columbus area.

One More Time: Men & Women’s
1803 W 5th Ave
Columbus, OH 43212
(614) 488-3006

Pink Door Consignment Boutique: Women’s
329 W Bridge St
Dublin, Ohio, OH 43017

Play it Again Sports: Sports gear
5 locations in Columbus

Plato’s Closet: Geared towards Juniors; Gals and Guys
5 locations in Columbus

Second Chance Consignment Boutique: Women’s
1803 W. 5th Avenue in Grandview

SOHO Luxury Exchange: Luxury bags, accessories, and more
12 W. Olentangy St.
Powell, Ohio
614-886-9190

Style Encore: Women
4904 Morse Rd
Gahanna, OH 43230
614-933-9999

Marigold Curated: Babies, Toddlers, Kids, and Women of all sizes, plus housewears
3045 Indianola Ave.
Columbus, Ohio
Online shopping available for some items
Open W-S, 11-5PM

Reynoldsburg Cancer Thrift Shop
7125 E. Main St., Reynoldsburg.
Hours: Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, Saturday – 12 noon – 4 p.m.
All proceeds support the Columbus Cancer Clinic
Call Mary at 614-762-7655 to inquire about making a donation to the shop.

Grove City Cancer Thrift Shop3684 Garden Court, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone: (614) 871-1126
Hours: Thursdays 12-4 p.m. and Saturdays 11 a.m. – 3 p.m. Listed hours are temporary due to current restrictions

Ink Recycling: Grove City Cancer Thrift Shop collects and recycles used/empty printer ink cartridges. They receive credit from Staples for these and use the dollars to buy supplies for the shop.
Staples and Staples.com purchases: After making a purchase at Staples or Staples.com, save that receipt. Grove City Cancer Thrift Shop receives credit for your sale and uses the credit to buy supplies for the shop.

In the nearly 50 years Grove City Cancer Thrift Shop has been in business, it has raised and donated nearly $1.1 million in support of cancer patients.

Worthington Thrift Shop5600 N. High St., Worthington, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 848-8408
Hours: Tuesday – Friday 1-4 p.m. and Saturdays 10 a.m. – 4 p.m. Consignments are taken Wednesdays and Thursdays 1-3 p.m. and Saturdays 10 a.m. – 1 p.m. Closed Sunday and Monday.

The Worthington Thrift Shop, established in 1967, is an all-volunteer 501 (c)(3) organization. The shop began raising money for the Columbus Cancer Clinic in 2006, totaling more than $250,000 for local cancer patients and their families. In addition, the shop runs pantry drives to collect non-perishable foods, toiletries and durable equipment for CCC.
The Worthington Thrift Shop accepts donations and does consignments. Individuals can consign small items (household, jewelry , shoes, handbags and clothing, no furniture) for a period of 30 days for a 50/50 split.

Uptown Cheapskate: Women’s and Men’s apparel, accessories, and shoes
5303 Westpointe Plaza Drive
Hilliard, OH 43026
(614) 363-4140
Mon-Sat: 10am-8pm,
Sunday: 12-6pm

Upscale Resales Furnishings: Home furnishings and accessories
189 W. Johnstown Road
Gahanna, Ohio 43230
(614) 476-4070

Looking for more? Check out our Garage Sales in Columbus page!